The Guardian recently published an article with this intriguing headline. Experts on schooling in the UK and USA argue that the way schools operate when adopting more formal approaches to pedagogy are stifling children’s curiosity, inquiry, and question asking.
There are many provocative statements to encourage those of you interested in promoting children’s inquiry and working theories through play-based inquiry pedagogies to add to your “response kit”. These will be useful when you are asked to articulate and justify your teaching and learning approaches.
Knowing the children they educate and care for has always been a foundational element of teachers’ professional knowledge.
To help children with their working theories then, teachers need to, as Ron Ritchart points out in the quote above, become “curious inquirers into the workings of their students’ minds”.
How might teachers do so? A few suggestions:
observe children closely when they are talking with each other and/or exploring an object/insect/play materials etc.
listen intently and carefully before asking questions or offering input
praise children’s contributions, including when they initially appear unconnected as that praise may encourage them to reveal the working of their mind
ask questions about children’s thinking (metacognition) as well as the ideas and concepts they seem to be exploring
While teacher talk has been a focus of many studies in early childhood education, recent research has noted that teachers listening and responding to children may be even more important. See:
Christopher, C., & Farran, D. (2020). Academic gains in kindergarten related to eight classroom practices. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 53, 638-649.
For further ideas about listening and responding to children see my article:
Hedges, H. (2021). Working theories: Current understandings and future directions. Early Childhood Folio, 25(1), 32-37. FREE FULL TEXT via https://doi.org/10.18296/ecf.0093
Many earlier posts have considered ways children’s curiosity and inquiry might be stimulated and developed. Twitter recently alerted me to someone else’s blog post about this. The post has a whole range of excellent ideas that connect with fostering children’s working theories. Enjoy reading it.
Daniel Lovatt gave a clear and thought-provoking presentation in our University of Auckland Early Childhood Seminar Series on Monday evening. He presented two models to help teachers to understand and respond to children’s working theories, and explained these with reference to two working theories – one the intriguing “flying sausages” in his title. The webinar was attended live by teachers, managers and leaders, professional learning and development providers, and teacher educators.
You can watch the recording on our YouTube channel:
You will also find recordings of many previous excellent seminars so this is a great resource for early childhood centre teams’ professional learning and discussions.
If you would like to be added to our mailing list to hear about upcoming seminars please email Dr Justine O’Hara-Gregan justine.ohara-gregan@auckland.ac.nz
Alison Gopnik is a psychology professor in the USA who has been studying children’s learning for many years. She has written several fabulous books on children’s learning, education and parenting.
Gopnik believes that children are born curious, and that theorising is an important way that they learn.
To lead you into locating and accessing her work further, I recommend the following excellent video of her talking about children’s learning and early childhood education (5 mins 41 seconds) in a great talk called “The amazing minds of very young children”.
I was delighted to launch my sole-authored book on children’s interests with my colleagues Maria Cooper and Justine O’Hara-Gregan at our university’s early childhood seminar series yesterday.
If you are interested in my book, or recommend to others – centre leaders or librarians for example – please let them know about the discount code to use on the Routledge website.
To purchase a copy of “Children’s interests, inquiries and identities” visit: https://www.routledge.com/Childrens-I… Use code: FLE22 at checkout for a 20% discount
A recording of the launch is available here:
Chapter 7 is the one about deeper interpretations of children’s interests and inquiries as working theories. Here is a word cloud of the chapter’s content – you will recognise many of the words from my blog posts.
I have posted previously about fostering curiosity and inquiry a few times. I came across this blog post about fostering awe in children, an emotion related to fostering curiosity, inquiry, working theories and eventual knowledge building.
Sometimes “awe moments” are a good reminder to adults to slow down and appreciate the world they live in too. The thoughtful comments about taking “awe walks” and the role of social media are worth pondering in our busy daily lives.
I had a new article published recently on working theories. I wrote it with two aims:
to bring together the research-to-date about working theories
to make this research accessible and “teacher-friendly” (kaiako is the word for teacher used in Te Whāriki), so the article could be used in teacher education and ongoing professional learning
After review, revision and acceptance, somewhat ironically, the publishers missed a step and it wasn’t published in the hard copy of the journal issue. This was despite the editorial by Linda Mitchell noting it should have been the lead article with the following kind commentary:
“Helen Hedges is well known for her pioneering research and ongoing scholarly interest in defining, theorising, and undertaking practice based research on children’s working theories, which she conveys here as encompassing “every aspect of human living and ways of knowing and being”. As several Aotearoa New Zealand studies have found, including those by Helen Hedges, working theories have been neglected as an outcome of Te Whāriki (Ministry of Education, 1996, 2017). It was only recently that kaiako were offered professional development on working theories. This article provides a clear and comprehensive review of a body of literature on working theories, mostly from Aotearoa New Zealand. It encompasses early scholarly literature on children as theorisers and current work to define and theorise the concept of working theories. The article then turns to research literature exemplifying working theories and exploring pedagogical knowledge and strategies to engage with and respond to children’s interests and theorising. An emphasis is on the importance of kaiako and researchers knowing children, families, and cultures well. Deeper understanding of theoretical underpinnings and access to this research-based literature will be helpful for kaiako wanting to understand working theories as a Te Whāriki outcome and to engage with children’s working theories in their curriculum, pedagogy, and assessment.” (Mitchell, 2021, p. 1)
The good news is that I asked if the article could be then made OPEN ACCESS and the response was YES!
The reference for the article is:
Hedges, H. (2021). Working theories: Current understandings and future directions. Early Childhood Folio25(1), 32-37. https://doi.org/10.18296/ecf.0093
Just click on the link and you will have access.
Please pass this URL/DOI link onto any others who may want to read it rather than sharing your downloaded copy.
Happy reading – go well with your support of children’s theorising.
I updated my bio earlier this year to note that I was writing a book. Hence my blog has been severely neglected yet again. However, the stats tell me it is still accessed regularly, and recently had quite an influx of readers reading multiple posts.
I suspect I have Simon Gregg to thank for that, so in return I share here his blog post where he shows – in mine and Guy Claxton’s terms – an adult/teacher working theory he is developing about children’s play with “loose parts”.
The more teachers – like Simon – who take the time to think through their own provision of resources, equipment and materials, ponder over the meanings of children’s play, and be responsive to ways children take that play, the richer the curriculum and pedagogy that children experience.
I have noted in an earlier post that one direction for research was/is particular topics of children’s working theories. I was delighted to find an article available online titled “Exploring children’s perceptions and working theories”. Rachel Winslow undertook her master’s thesis focusing on the potential of the Arts to support in-depth conversations and interactions with children about matters of importance to children (and societies).
Rachel indicates in this article that working theories about kindness are one of the themes that she located in children’s theorising. This theme has become even more pertinent in New Zealand during the corona virus pandemic as our Prime Minister in New Zealand, Jacinda Ardern, has consistently communicated a need to be kind to one another as we work our way through these difficult times.
Unfortunately, Rachel’s thesis is not available publicly through a database, so I am hopeful that she is working on a publication about her findings so we can hear more about children’s working theories about kindness.
Meantime, I offer a Māori whakataukī (proverb) about kindness:
He aroha whakatō, he aroha ka puta mai
If kindness is sown, then kindness if what you shall receive
Source: Mauri Ora: Wisdom from theMāori world (2016)